Home > Forecasts & Analyses > The National Energy Modeling System: An Overview > Petroleum Market Module

The National Energy Modeling System: An Overview
  Full Printer-Friendly VersionPDF GIF


Find on this page:

Petroleum Market Module

bullet gif  Regions
bullet gif  Product Categories
bullet gif  Fuel Use
bullet gif  Crude Oil Categories
bullet gif  Refinery Processes
bullet gif  Natural Gas Plants
bullet gif  Biofuels
bullet gif  End-Use Markups
bullet gif  Gasoline Types
bullet gif  Ultra-Low-Sulfur Diesel
bullet gif  Gas, Coal and Biomass to Limits


Chapters in this Report:

Introduction/Overview of NEMS
Carbon Dioxide Emissions
Modules:
  Macroeconomic
  International Energy
  Residential Demand
  Commercial Demand

  Industrial Demand
  Transportation Demand

  Electricity Market
  Renewable Fuels
  Oil and Gas Supply
  Natural Gas Transmission & Distribution
  Petroleum Market Module

  Coal Market Module
Petroleum Market Module    

The PMM represents domestic refinery operations and the marketing of liquid fuels  to  consumption  regions.  PMM solves for liquid fuel prices, crude oil and product import activity (in conjunction with the IEM and the OGSM), and domestic refinery capacity expansion and fuel consumption. The solution satisfies the demand for liquid fuels, incorporating the prices for raw material inputs, imported liquid fuels, capital investment, as well as the domestic production of crude oil, natural gas liquids, and other unconventional refinery inputs. The relationship of PMM to other NEMS modules is illustrated in Figure 16. 

The PMM is a regional,  linear programming formulation of the five Petroleum Administration for Defense Districts (PADDs) (Figure 17).  For each region two distinct refinery are modeled. One is highly complex using over 40 different refinrry processes, while the second is defined as a simple refinery that provides marginal cost economics.  Refining capacity is allowed to expand in each region, but the model does not distinguish between additions to existing refineries or the building of new facilities. Investment criteria are developed exogenously, although the decision to invest is endogenous. 

PMM assumes that the petroleum refining and marketing industry is competitive. The market will move toward lower-cost refiners who have access to crude oil and markets. The selection of crude oils, refinery process  utilization,  and  logistics (transportation) will adjust to minimize the overall cost of supplying the market with liquid fuels. 

PMM's model formulation reflects the operation of domestic liquuid fuels. If demand is unusually high in one region, the price will increase, driving down demand and providing economic incentives for bringing supplies in from other regions, thus restoring the supply and demand balance. 

Existing regulations concerning product types and specifications, the cost of environmental compliance, and Federal and State taxes are also modeled. PMM incorporates provisions from the Energy Independence and Security Act of 2007 (EISA2007) and the Energy Policy Act of 2005 (EPACT05). The costs of producing new formulations of gasoline and diesel fuel as a result of the CAAA90 are determined within the linear-programming representation by incorporating specifications and demands for these fuels. 

PMM also includes the interaction between the domestic and international markets.  Prior to AEO2009, PMM postulated entirely exogenous prices for oil on the international market (the world oil price).  Subsequent AEOs include an International Energy Module (IEM) that estimates supply curves for imported crude oils and products based on, among other factors, U.S. participation in global trade of crude oil and liquid fuels.


Table describing PMM Outputs.  Need help, contact the National Energy Information Center at 202-586-8800.
 
Figure 16. Petrolum Market Module Structure.  Need help, contact the National Energy Information Center at 202-586-8800.
Click for a larger version

Figure 17. Petroleum Administration by Defense Districts.  Need help, contact the National Energy Information Center at 202-586-8800.
Click for a larger version
Regions   back to top

PMM models U.S. crude oil refining capabilities based on the five PADDs which were established during World War II and are still used by EIA for data collection and analysis. The use of PADD data permits PMM to take full advantage of EIA’s historical database and allows analysis within the same framework used by the petroleum industry.


 

Product Categories   back to top

Product categories, specifications and recipe blends modeled in PMM include the following:

Liquid Fuels Modeled in PMM

Table describing Liquid Fuels Modelin in PMM.  Need help, contact the National Energy Information Center at 202-586-8800.


 
Fuel Use   back to top

PMM determines refinery fuel use by refining region for purchased electricity, natural gas, distillate fuel, residual fuel, liquefied petroleum gas, and other petroleum. The fuels (natural gas, petroleum, other gaseous fuels, and other) consumed within the refinery to generate electricity from CHP facilities are also determined.

 
Crude Oil Categories   back to top

Both domestic and imported crude oils are aggregated into five categories as defined by API gravity and sulfur content ranges.  This aggregation of crude oil types allows PMM to account for changes in crude oil composition over time. A composite crude oil with the appropriate yields and qualities is developed for each category by averaging characteristics of foreign and domestic crude oil streams. 

   
Refinery Processes   back to top

The following distinct processes are represented in the PMM:

Table describing Refinery Processes that are represented in the PMM.  Need help, contact the National Energy Information Center at 202-586-8800.


   
Natural Gas Plants   back to top

Natural gas plant liquids (ethane, propane, normal butane, isobutane, and natural gasoline) produced from natural gas processing plants are modeled in PMM. Their production levels are based on the projected natural gas supply and historical liquids yields from various natural gas sources. These products move directly into the market to meet demand (e.g., for fuel or petrochemical feedstocks) or are inputs to the refinery. 

   
Biofuels   back to top

PMM contains submodules which provide regional supplies and prices for biofuels: ethanol (conventional/corn, advanced, cellulosic) and various forms of biomass-based diesel: FAME (methyl ester), biomass-to-liquid (Fisher-Tropsch), and renewable (“green”) diesel (hydrogenation of vegetable oils or fats). Ethanol is assumed to be blended either at 10 percent into gasoline (conventional or reformulated) or as E85. Food feedstock supply curves (corn, soybean oil, etc.) are updated to USDA baseline projections; biomass feedstocks are drawn from the same supply curves that also supply biomass fuel to renewable power generation within the Renewable Fuels Module of NEMS. The merchant processing units which generate the biofuels supplies sum these feedstock costs with other cost inputs (e.g., capital, operating). A major driving force behind the production of these biofuels is the Renewable Fuels Standard under EISA2007. Details on the market penetration of the advanced biofuels production capacity (such as cellulosic ethanol and BTL) which are not yet commercialized can be found in the PMM documentation. 

   
End-Use Markups   back to top

The linear programming portion of the model provides unit prices of products sold in the refinery regions (refinery gate) and in the demand regions (wholesale). End use markups are added to produce a retail price for each of the Census Divisions. The mark ups are based on an average of historical markups, defined as the difference between the end-use prices by sector and the corresponding wholesale price for that product. The average is calculated using data from 2000 to the present. Because of the lack of any consistent trend in the historical end-use markups, the markups remain at the historical average level over the projection period. 

State and Federal taxes are also added to transportation fuel prices to determine final end-use prices.  Previous tax trend analysis indicates that state taxes increase at the rate of inflation, while Federal taxes do not.  In PMM, therefore state taxes are held constant in real terms throughout the projection while Federal taxes are felated at the rate of inflation.18

   
Gasoline Types   back to top

Motor vehicle fuel in PMM is categorized into four gasoline blends (conventional, oxygenated conventional, reformulated, and California reformulated) and also E85. While federal law does not mandate gasoline to be oxygenated, all gasoline complying with the Federal reformulated gasoline program is assumed to contain 10 percent ethanol, while conventional gasoline may be “clear” (no ethanol) or used as E10. As the mandate for biofuels grows under the Renewable Fuels Standard, the proportion of conventional gasoline that is E10 also generally grows. California reformulated motor gasoline is assumed to contain 5.7% ethanol in 2009 and 10 percent thereafter in line with its approval of the use of California’s Phase 3 reformulated gasoline. 

EIA defines E85 as a gasoline type but is treated as a separate fuel in PMM. The transportation module in NEMS provides PMM with a flex fuel vehicle (FFV) demand, and PMM computes a supply curve for E85. This curve incorporates E85 infrastructure and station costs, as well as a logit relationship between the E85 station availability and demand of E85. Infrastructure costs dictate that the E85 supplies emerge in the Midwest first, followed by an expansion to the coasts.

   
Ultra-Low-Sulfur Diesel   back to top

By definition, Ultra Low Sulfur Diesel (ULSD) is highway diesel fuel that contains no more than 15 ppm sulfur at the pump.  As of June 2006, 80 percent of all highway diesel produced or imported into the United States was required to be ULSD, while the remaining 20 percent contained a maximum of 500 parts per million.  By December 1, 2010 all highway fuel sold at the pump will be required to be ULSD.  Major assumptions related to the ULSD rule are as follows: 

  • Highway diesel at the refinery gate will contain a maximum of 7-ppm sulfur. Although sulfur content is limited to 15 ppm at the pump, there is a general consensus that refineries will need to produce diesel below 10 ppm sulfur in order to allow for contamination during the distribution process. 
  • Demand for highway grade diesel, both 500 and 15 ppm combined, is assumed to be equivalent to the total transportation distillate demand. Historically, highway grade diesel supplied has nearly matched total transportation distillate sales, although some highway grade diesel has gone to non-transportation uses such as construction and agriculture.
   
Gas, Coal and Biomass to Liquids   back to top

Natural gas, coal, and biomass conversion to liquid fuels is modeled in the PMM based on a three step process known as indirect liquefaction. This process is sometimes called Fischer-Tropsch (FT) liquefaction after the inventors of the second step.  

The liquid fuels produced include four separate products: FT light naphtha, FT heavy naphtha, FT kerosene, and FT diesel. The FT designation is used to distinguish these liquid fuels from their petroleum counterparts. This is necessary due to the different physical and chemical properties of the FT fuels. For example, FT diesel has a typical cetane rating of approximately 70-75 while that of petroleum diesel is typically much lower (about 40). In addition, the above production methods have differing impacts with regard to current and potential legislation, particularly RFS and CO2.

   
   

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Preface and Contacts
Appendix

Notes and Sources

 
Chapters in this Report:

Introduction/Overview of NEMS
Carbon Dioxide Emissions
Modules:
  Macroeconomic
  International Energy
  Residential Demand
  Commercial Demand

  Industrial Demand
  Transportation Demand

  Electricity Market
  Renewable Fuels
  Oil and Gas Supply
  Natural Gas Transmission & Distribution
  Petroleum Market Module

  Coal Market Module