Are High Crude Prices Due to the “Wrong” Crude Oil being Available?
IMPACT
OBSERVATION
But better than none
Heavy crude not the “best” to meet demand
Theoretically, conversion capacity becomes fully utilized, yield of residual fuel increases
High refining utilization
More heavy crude oil means downward heavy price pressure
Marginal crude production is heavy
Lower residual fuel prices relative to crude, thus downward heavy crude price pressure
High crude oil prices
SSome market observers have said that the increase in crude oil price is being driven by the fact that the latest increases in crude oil production have been mostly heavy crude oils, and heavy crude oils are the wrong crude oils to serve demand needs. They contend that what is really needed by refiners is light, low-sulfur crude oil, and that production of the wrong crude oil is driving up prices.

SMy view is production of heavy crude oil increases the price difference between light and heavy crude oil, and that an increase in this price difference does not translate to a higher overall price.  In fact I argue just the opposite -- that high crude oil prices tend to increase the price difference apart from any increases in heavy crude oil production.  High light-heavy crude price differences do not drive higher prices.  The dynamics of situation are described on this slide.

SHigher crude oil prices increase the price difference between residual fuel prices and prices for gasoline and distillate.  Residual fuel price is affected by alternative fuel prices and generally does not increase with crude oil prices.  That by itself, tends to keep the prices of heavy crude oils from increasing as fast as light crude oils.

SIf marginal volumes of crude oil production are heavy, that further depresses heavy crude oil prices.

SFinally, if refineries are running at high utilizations, one might expect yield of residual fuel to increase as conversion capacity becomes fully utilized, which helps to keep heavy crude oil prices lower than lighter crude oils.

SBut those heavy crude oils are still used, and having those volumes is better than not having any increased volumes